Buyer-first futures comparison · checked October 13, 2026
Lucid Trading vs TradeDay Buyer’s Scorecard
Lucid Trading and TradeDay both sell futures evaluations with a $3,000 target and a $2,000 drawdown at 50K, charge no activation fee and let funded traders request money early. They are built differently: Lucid charges once, pays 90/10 from the first payout and caps most payouts, while TradeDay bills every 30 days until you pass, lets Quick Pay traders withdraw from the first funded day with no cap, but pays 50/50 until the account holds $4,000 of profit and reviews each account for live at $10,000.
| Decision point | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Matched product | 50K LucidDaily (daily payout requests, intraday funded drawdown, no per-payout cap) | 50K Quick Pay (requests from the first funded day, intraday funded drawdown, no per-payout cap) |
| Entry price | $136 (EOD evaluation) or $108 (intraday), paid once; $95.20 / $75.60 with Lucid’s published VAULT code, DLL on | $175 (EOD evaluation) or $131 (intraday) every 30 days until you pass; $79 / $59 at the sale price on TradeDay’s cards |
| Activation / resets | $0 activation; no monthly billing; reset $95 (EOD) or $75 (intraday) | $0 activation; billing stops when you pass; a renewal resets a failed evaluation free; paid reset $79 (EOD) or $59 (intraday) |
| Profit target / minimum days | $3,000; passable in two days through the consistency cushion | $3,000; at least 5 trading days |
| Evaluation loss rules | $2,000 EOD or intraday (your choice at checkout); optional $1,200 soft daily loss limit | $2,000 EOD or intraday trailing (separate products); no daily loss limit |
| Evaluation consistency | 50% | 30%: a bigger best day raises the target instead of failing you |
| Funded drawdown | $2,000 intraday; locks at $50,100 once the balance passes $52,100 | $2,000 intraday, trailing on gross profit so payouts do not lower it; stops at $50,000 |
| Funded payout gate | Balance above the $52,100 buffer, any net profit since the last payout, $500 minimum, request daily | Any positive balance from the first funded day, no buffer, $250 minimum |
| Profit split | 90/10 | 50/50 while the account holds under $4,000 of profit, 80/20 on the part above; 90/10 in Funded Live |
| Move to live | Earning the $8,000 maximum daily profit triggers the move | The account pauses at $10,000 gross profit for a live review; profit above $10,000 is removed |
| News and automation | Flat 1 minute either side of high-impact USD news (hard breach); bots and copiers allowed | All accounts flattened 2 minutes either side of FOMC, CPI and payrolls; own strategy allowed, bought bots and VPS not |
| Best fit | Traders who want a one-time fee, 90/10 from the first payout, EOD funded options on other plans, automation and news trading on Pro, Flex and Direct. | Traders who want the cheapest fast first attempt, day-one withdrawals, no daily loss limit, Treasury futures and a published 36% pass rate, and can keep $4,000 in the account. |
Advanced checks before paying
- Price TradeDay by the months you expect to need: the fee repeats every 30 days until you pass or cancel, though a renewal also gives a failed account a free reset.
- Model your payouts with the Quick Pay split: below $4,000 of account profit you keep 50%, and profit under $4,000 still in the account when it moves to Funded Live is also transferred at 50%.
- Check the funded drawdown you will actually have. Quick Pay and LucidDaily trail intraday once funded, even after an EOD evaluation; Fast Pass, LucidPro, LucidFlex and LucidDirect stay EOD.
- If you run a bot, use a VPS or trade CPI and FOMC releases, read each firm’s rule on your exact plan before paying.
Figures are tied to the products named in each row and were read from each firm’s public pages and help centre on October 13, 2026. Coupon and sale prices are read from published list prices, cards and codes, not verified by purchase. Recheck checkout before paying.
Short answer:Lucid Trading vs TradeDay comes down to how you pay and how much of each payout you keep. Lucid charges a one-time fee, pays 90/10 from the first payout on all four plans (LucidPro, LucidFlex, LucidDaily and the no-evaluation LucidDirect) and allows bots and copiers, but it caps each payout on Pro, Flex and Direct. TradeDay bills its evaluation every 30 days ($59 a month for a 50K Quick Pay intraday account at the sale price shown on October 13, 2026, $131 list), charges no activation fee and lets Quick Pay traders withdraw from the first funded day with no buffer and no cap. The catch is the split: Quick Pay pays 50/50 while the account holds less than $4,000 of profit and 80/20 above that, and it pauses each account at $10,000 of gross profit for a live review, removing anything above that level. TradeDay also flattens every account around FOMC, CPI and payrolls, bans bought bots and VPS use, and publishes a 36% pass rate. Neither firm is better for everyone.
This page compares Lucid Trading and TradeDay plan by plan. Every number below comes from the firms’ own websites and help centres, read on October 13, 2026, and the sources are listed at the end. Where a firm’s own pages disagree, we say so.
Checked October 13, 2026: lucidtrading.com, support.lucidtrading.com, tradeday.com and the TradeDay help centre (tradeday.freshdesk.com). Sale prices and coupon prices were read from the firms’ public pages on October 13, 2026; they were not verified by purchase.
Both firms run simulated evaluation and funded accounts. Payouts from the funded stage are paid from simulated profits under each firm’s rules, and only some traders reach live capital. This is educational research, not financial advice.
Lucid Trading vs TradeDay at a glance
| Factor | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Public plans | LucidPro, LucidFlex, LucidDaily (evaluations) and LucidDirect (straight to funded) | Quick Pay (intraday or end-of-day evaluation) and Fast Pass (end-of-day evaluation), each followed by Funded Sim and then Funded Live |
| Account sizes | 25K, 50K, 100K, 150K on every plan | 25K, 50K, 100K, 150K on every plan |
| Fee model | One-time fee, no subscription, $0 activation | Monthly subscription (every 30 days) until you pass or cancel, $0 activation; a renewal resets a failed evaluation for free |
| Profit split | 90/10 on every plan | Quick Pay: 50/50 below $4,000 of account profit, 80/20 above. Fast Pass: 80/20. Funded Live: 90/10 |
| First withdrawal | LucidDaily: any day once above the buffer. LucidPro: after the profit goal and 40% rule. LucidFlex: after 5 profitable days. LucidDirect: after the profit goal, 20% rule and 5 days | Quick Pay: from funded day one with any positive balance, no buffer. Fast Pass: after 5 profitable days and the 45% rule |
| Payout cap | $1,000 to $3,500 per payout on Pro, Flex and Direct by size; none on LucidDaily | Quick Pay: none per payout, but each account is paused at $10,000 gross profit. Fast Pass: 50% of profit, up to $750 to $2,250 by size |
| Funded drawdown | EOD on Pro, Flex and Direct; intraday on LucidDaily | Quick Pay: intraday on every account, even after an EOD evaluation. Fast Pass: EOD |
| Daily loss limit | Optional soft limit on Pro, Flex and Daily (chosen at checkout); fixed then scaling on Direct | None on any plan |
| News | Allowed on Pro, Flex and Direct; LucidDaily is a hard breach within 1 minute of high-impact USD news | All accounts are flattened 2 minutes before and reopened 2 minutes after FOMC, CPI and Non-Farm Payrolls (plus EIA and crop reports for those markets) |
| Bots and automation | Automated systems and trade copiers allowed if they follow the rules | Your own automated strategy on supported platforms; bought bots, platform APIs and VPS are not allowed |
| Platforms | CQG: NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView. Rithmic: Quantower, Tradesea, MotiveWave, Sierra Chart, Jigsaw, Bookmap, ATAS, R|Trader Pro, MultiCharts | CQG: Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView, Jigsaw. Rithmic (added August 2026): R|Trader Pro, Quantower, ATAS, MotiveWave, Bookmap, Jigsaw, Sierra Chart, EdgeProX, Finamark, VolFix, WealthCharts, MultiCharts, Overcharts |
| Payout delivery | Plaid (US), WorkMarket by ADP (bank or PayPal), crypto for international traders | Riseworks: bank wire (free in the US, $15 international) or crypto |
| Inactivity | Deleted after 30 calendar days without a $1 net profit or loss | Accounts dormant for 30 days may be offboarded; Tradovate archives an account not logged into for a calendar month |
| Refunds | No refund once traded; untraded accounts at Lucid’s discretion | No refund after purchase; a forgotten renewal can be refunded within 72 hours, minus 20%, if you have not traded or connected since |
| Trustpilot (read October 13, 2026) | 4.4 from 6,880 reviews | 4.6 from 1,446 reviews |
What each firm is and how its model works
Lucid Trading is run by Lucid Trading Group LLC, which lists a Dover, Delaware address. Its help-centre articles are signed by “AJ”, and the firm’s official X account calls AJ its founder and CEO; outside event listings name him as AJ Campanella. Lucid sells four current plans: LucidPro (pass in one day, larger caps from payout 2), LucidFlex (cheapest, no funded consistency rule, payouts of 50% of profit), LucidDaily (daily payout requests, intraday funded drawdown) and LucidDirect (no evaluation). The older LucidBlack plan and the earlier Live and LucidMaxx structures are legacy and are not compared here. Funded accounts are simulated; traders enter a live review pool after their fifth payout on Pro, Flex or Direct, or after hitting the maximum daily profit on LucidDaily. Our Lucid Trading review covers every plan, and Lucid’s plans compared helps you choose between them.
TradeDay is TradeDay LLC, an Illinois company at 412 S. Wells in Chicago, founded in 2020 by James Thorpe (CEO) and Steve Miley (COO). Its About page dates its first payouts to 2021, multiple accounts to June 2025 and “TradeDay 2.0” to June 2026; the 2.0 announcement is dated May 29, 2026 and says traders already in older programs keep their existing rules. TradeDay calls itself a trading education and trader evaluation company and says it is not registered with the SEC or CFTC. It has two paths, both in three stages:
- Quick Pay: a 5-day evaluation with a 30% consistency objective, then a Funded Sim account with day-one payouts, then a Funded Live account after a review at $10,000 gross profit.
- Fast Pass: a 3-day evaluation with a 45% consistency objective, then a Funded Sim account with profitable-day and cap rules, then Funded Live on the fifth payout request.
The monthly fee also buys access to TradeDay’s members’ area (courses, daily meetings, a trading room). TradeDay sells that on its own as a “CoPilot” membership from $24 a month for people who do not want an evaluation.
The practical difference: Lucid gives you four ways in, pays 90% of every payout from the first one and caps how much each payout can be. TradeDay lets you take money out from the first funded day on Quick Pay and has no per-payout cap there, but keeps half of what you withdraw until the account holds more than $4,000 of profit, and stops each account at $10,000 of gross profit for a live review.
Lucid Trading vs TradeDay prices at 25K, 50K, 100K and 150K
The fee models are different, so compare what you expect to pay in total. Lucid charges once per evaluation. TradeDay charges every 30 days until you pass or cancel; billing stops the day you pass and there is no activation fee. Lucid’s homepage shows the code VAULT for 30% off, plus a limited-time $5 to $10 discount for keeping the daily loss limit on with LucidPro and LucidFlex. TradeDay’s pricing cards on October 13, 2026 showed list prices struck through with sale prices of about 55% off Quick Pay and 50% off Fast Pass (“Accounts from just $45!”), and its banner said “USE CODE TDNEW” for best pricing. TradeDay does not say whether TDNEW changes the sale price shown, so we print the card prices. BestProps has no codes of its own; our Lucid Trading deals and TradeDay deals pages track current offers.
| Lucid plan (one-time fee) | 25K | 50K | 100K | 150K |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LucidFlex list | $79 | $136 | $258 | $372 |
| LucidFlex with VAULT, DLL on | $50.30 | $90.20 | $170.60 | $250.40 |
| LucidPro list | $108 | $172 | $272 | $365 |
| LucidPro with VAULT, DLL on | $70.60 | $115.40 | $180.40 | $245.50 |
| LucidDaily list (EOD / intraday evaluation) | $93 / $79 | $136 / $108 | $222 / $179 | $315 / $258 |
| LucidDaily with VAULT, DLL on (EOD / intraday) | $65.10 / $55.30 | $95.20 / $75.60 | $155.40 / $125.30 | $220.50 / $180.60 |
| LucidDirect list (straight to funded) | $329 | $515 | $700 | $836 |
| LucidDirect with VAULT | $230.30 | $360.50 | $490.00 | $585.20 |
| LucidPro reset | $70 | $115 | $180 | $245 |
| TradeDay (per 30 days until you pass) | 25K | 50K | 100K | 150K |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quick Pay intraday, list | $100 | $131 | $240 | $360 |
| Quick Pay intraday, sale price on the card | $45 | $59 | $108 | $162 |
| Quick Pay end of day, list | $120 | $175 | $285 | $400 |
| Quick Pay end of day, sale price on the card | $54 | $79 | $129 | $180 |
| Fast Pass (end of day), list | $130 | $189 | $350 | $530 |
| Fast Pass, sale price on the card | $65 | $95 | $175 | $265 |
| Activation fee | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Paid reset (Quick Pay intraday / Quick Pay EOD / Fast Pass), help centre | $45 / $54 / $65 | $59 / $79 / $95 | $96 / $129 / $165 | $144 / $180 / $250 |
Three TradeDay source conflicts to know about. First, the pricing cards print a reset price equal to the sale price, which matches the help centre at 25K and 50K but not at 100K and 150K (cards: $108 and $162 on Quick Pay intraday, $175 and $265 on Fast Pass; help centre: $96, $144, $165 and $250). Second, TradeDay’s “differences between each account size” article (updated September 1, 2026) lists lower list prices than the cards for several plans, for example $125 rather than $131 for the 50K Quick Pay intraday and $480 rather than $530 for the 150K Fast Pass. Third, the 2.0 launch post advertised the 50K from $62.50. We use the pricing cards as the current offer; check checkout before paying.
Free resets on renewal. Each TradeDay subscription includes one evaluation per 30 days. If you have failed and your dashboard shows “NOT BEING EVALUATED” when the renewal goes through, TradeDay resets the account for free; the reset is not banked for later. A paid reset restarts you immediately and does not move the billing date. Lucid has no renewal, so every restart is a paid reset.
What it costs to reach the funded stage at 50K
Because one firm bills monthly and the other does not, the number of months you need changes the answer. These scenarios use TradeDay’s card sale prices and Lucid’s VAULT prices with the daily loss limit on.
| Scenario (50K) | TradeDay Quick Pay intraday | TradeDay Quick Pay EOD | TradeDay Fast Pass | LucidPro | LucidDaily EOD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pass within the first 30 days | $59 | $79 | $95 | $115.40 | $95.20 |
| Pass in the second month | $118 | $158 | $190 | $115.40 | $95.20 |
| Pass in the third month | $177 | $237 | $285 | $115.40 | $95.20 |
| Fail once, buy a reset, pass in month one | $59 + $59 = $118 | $79 + $79 = $158 | $95 + $95 = $190 | $115.40 + $115 = $230.40 | $95.20 + $95 = $190.20 |
| Fail once, wait for the renewal reset, pass in month two | $118 | $158 | $190 | Not applicable | Not applicable |
| Same first-month pass at list price | $131 | $175 | $189 | $172 | $136 |
Cost check: at the sale prices on October 13, 2026, a first-month 50K pass is cheaper at TradeDay on Quick Pay ($59 to $79) than on any Lucid plan except LucidFlex ($90.20) and the intraday LucidDaily ($75.60). From the second month, Lucid’s one-time fee is usually cheaper. If you pass in two or three days, the subscription costs you once; if you expect to grind for two months, add the second payment before you compare.
Other costs
Commissions in the simulated accounts. Both firms charge per side. TradeDay says its rates include brokerage, NFA, clearing and exchange fees and are the same on evaluation, Funded Sim and Funded Live accounts. Lucid labels its rate “Commission (Per Side)” without saying what it includes.
| Contract | Lucid per side (round trip) | TradeDay per side (round trip) |
|---|---|---|
| ES / NQ / RTY / YM | $1.75 ($3.50) | $2.88 ($5.76) |
| MES / MNQ / M2K / MYM | $0.50 ($1.00) | $0.95 ($1.90) |
| CL / MCL | $2.00 / $0.50 | $3.00 / $1.10 |
| GC / MGC | $2.30 / $0.80 | $3.10 / $1.20 |
| 6E (euro futures) | $2.40 | $3.10 |
| 10-year Treasury note (ZN) | Not on the approved list | $2.30 |
Example: 20 round trips a day on MNQ for 20 trading days costs $400 at Lucid and $760 at TradeDay at the published rates. On five ES round trips a day for 20 days it is $350 against $576. Commission comes out of your profit and your drawdown at both firms, so a high-frequency style pays noticeably more at TradeDay.
Market data. TradeDay includes Level 1 CME data free in the evaluation and Funded Sim. Level 2 is a $49 a month bundle bought inside Tradovate. In Funded Live you pay the CME professional data fee of $156 per exchange per month, plus a $2 a month card fee that Tradovate charges, and your commissions are debited from the account. Lucid’s live-account articles do not publish a data charge; its setup guide lists professional data at $112 per exchange per month.
Withdrawal fees. TradeDay pays through Riseworks: US bank wires are free, international wires cost $15, Layer 1 crypto costs $2.50 plus gas and Layer 2 crypto is free. Lucid does not publish a payout fee; its minimum request is $500 against TradeDay’s $250.
Platform licences. TradeDay provides a free NinjaTrader 8 licence on its CQG route; TradingView, Jigsaw, Bookmap and the other add-ons need your own licence. Lucid provides MotiveWave and Quantower licences through its dashboard.
Evaluation rules: targets, minimum days and how hard each is to pass
| Account | Profit target (25K / 50K / 100K / 150K) | Minimum days | Evaluation consistency | Max size (minis) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LucidPro | $1,250 / $3,000 / $6,000 / $9,000 | 1 day | None | 2 / 4 / 6 / 10 |
| LucidFlex | $1,250 / $3,000 / $6,000 / $9,000 | 2 days in practice (50% rule with a cushion) | 50% | 2 / 4 / 6 / 10 |
| LucidDaily | $1,250 / $3,000 / $6,000 / $9,000 | 2 days in practice (50% rule with a cushion) | 50% | 2 / 4 / 6 / 10 |
| LucidDirect | No evaluation | 5 days before the first payout | 20% in the funded stage | 2 / 4 / 6 / 10 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay | $1,500 / $3,000 / $6,000 / $9,000 | 5 trading days | 30% (no day above 30% of total profit) | 2 / 5 / 10 / 15 (micros capped at 20 / 50 / 50 / 50) |
| TradeDay Fast Pass | $1,500 / $3,000 / $6,000 / $9,000 | 3 trading days | 45% | 2 / 5 / 10 / 15 in the evaluation; 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 once funded, scaling up |
Ease of passing. On paper Lucid has fewer gates: LucidPro can pass in one day with no consistency test, and LucidFlex and LucidDaily need about two days. TradeDay Quick Pay needs five trading days and a 30% consistency objective, the strictest evaluation rule in this comparison. TradeDay also warns that if you hit the target early you must keep trading “in the style you have been”; sitting in the “funding zone” scalping 1-lot micros can get the evaluation extended. In exchange, TradeDay has no daily loss limit at all, while Lucid’s optional daily limit is a soft stop for the rest of the session. TradeDay publishes a pass rate of 36% for January to June 2026. We found no pass-rate figure from Lucid.
A Fast Pass source conflict. TradeDay’s pricing cards and help centre say Fast Pass needs 3 minimum trading days; the How It Works page and the 2.0 launch post say “No minimum on Fast Pass”. Plan for 3 days.
What TradeDay checks after you pass. Passing is not a guarantee. TradeDay reviews every passed evaluation for prohibited practices, runs KYC and AML checks through Riseworks, and requires a rules-and-regulations course. You get a pass email at 5:30 PM CT, and you have 30 days to finish the four onboarding steps or the offer lapses. If you fail KYC, TradeDay refunds the fee for the passed evaluation but not earlier months.
Lucid Trading and TradeDay drawdown rules: EOD, intraday and where they stop
| Account | Evaluation drawdown | Funded drawdown | Amount (25K / 50K / 100K / 150K) | Where it stops |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LucidPro / LucidFlex | EOD | EOD | $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500 | Starting balance + $100 once the balance closes above the initial trail balance (e.g. $50,100 after $52,100 on 50K) |
| LucidDaily | EOD or intraday (chosen at checkout) | Intraday | $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500 | Starting balance + $100 |
| LucidDirect | No evaluation | EOD | $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,500 / $5,000 | Starting balance + $100 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay | Intraday or EOD (separate products) | Intraday on every Quick Pay account, trailing on gross profit | $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500 | The starting balance (e.g. $50,000 on 50K) |
| TradeDay Fast Pass | EOD | EOD | $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500 | The starting balance; on the first payout request it jumps straight to the starting balance and stays there |
The Quick Pay EOD trap. TradeDay sells a “Quick Pay End of Day” evaluation, but its card adds “(Intraday Funded Drawdown)”: once you pass, the Funded Sim account trails intraday, including open profit. LucidDaily works the same way. If you chose EOD because you let winners breathe, only LucidPro, LucidFlex, LucidDirect and TradeDay Fast Pass keep an EOD drawdown after funding.
Payouts do not pull the Quick Pay floor back down. TradeDay calculates the Quick Pay floor on gross profit (current profit plus payouts already taken), so it keeps trailing as if the withdrawn money were still there. TradeDay’s own 50K example: make $500 on day one and the floor rises from $48,000 to $48,500; withdraw that $500 and the balance is back at $50,000 but the floor stays at $48,500. Every payout before the floor reaches $50,000 shrinks your cushion by the full amount withdrawn. TradeDay adds that traders whose frequent or large withdrawals leave the account exposed may not be invited back after a loss.
No daily loss limit at TradeDay. The maximum drawdown is TradeDay’s one rule that ends an account. At Lucid the daily loss limit is a soft breach (trading stops until the next session) and is optional on Pro, Flex and Daily: you decide at checkout and cannot change it later. On LucidPro and LucidDirect, once the funded balance closes above the trail balance, a scaling limit of 60% of your peak end-of-day profit replaces the fixed one. More on Lucid’s mechanics in Lucid Trading rules and on TradeDay’s in TradeDay rules.
Lucid Trading and TradeDay consistency rules
Both firms divide your best day by your total profit, and missing the ratio does not fail the account at either firm; you keep trading until it is back in line.
| Account | Evaluation | Funded (per payout cycle) |
|---|---|---|
| LucidPro | None | 40% (35% for accounts bought or reset before November 28, 2025, 3 PM EST) |
| LucidFlex | 50% | None |
| LucidDaily | 50% | None |
| LucidDirect | No evaluation | 20% |
| TradeDay Quick Pay | 30% | None |
| TradeDay Fast Pass | 45% | 45% of gross profit for accounts opened on or after July 26, 2026; none for older accounts |
Worked example, 50K evaluation. Days of +$1,200, +$900 and +$900 make $3,000, which hits the target, but the $1,200 day is 40% of the total. On TradeDay Quick Pay you must keep going until that day is 30% of profit: $1,200 ÷ 0.30 = $4,000, the same example TradeDay gives. On Fast Pass, 40% is under 45%, so $3,000 passes once you have 3 days. LucidFlex and LucidDaily (50%) pass, and LucidPro has no evaluation rule. TradeDay’s own tip: keep every day under $900 on a 50K Quick Pay ($3,000 × 30%) and under $1,350 on Fast Pass.
Worked example, funded. A $1,200 best day needs $3,000 in the cycle on LucidPro (40%), $6,000 on LucidDirect (20%) and about $2,667 of gross profit on a new Fast Pass account (45%). On Quick Pay, LucidDaily and LucidFlex there is no funded rule. Our Lucid Trading consistency rule guide has calculator tables for each Lucid plan.
Lucid Trading vs TradeDay payouts: split, timing, minimums and caps
| Account | Split | When you can request | Buffer before the first request (25K / 50K / 100K / 150K) | Minimum | Maximum per payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LucidPro | 90/10 | Any day once the profit goal ($250 / $500 / $750 / $1,000) and 40% rule are met | $26,100 / $52,100 / $103,100 / $154,600 | $500 | Payout 1: $1,000 / $2,000 / $2,500 / $3,000. Payouts 2+: $1,500 / $2,500 / $3,000 / $3,500 |
| LucidFlex | 90/10 | After every 5 days with at least $100 / $150 / $200 / $250 profit | None | $500 | 50% of profit, up to $1,000 / $2,000 / $2,500 / $3,000 |
| LucidDaily | 90/10 | Daily, with any net profit since the last payout | $26,100 / $52,100 / $103,100 / $154,600 | $500 | All profit above the buffer |
| LucidDirect | 90/10 | Any day once the profit goal and 20% rule are met; 5-day minimum | Profit goal $1,500 / $3,000 / $6,000 / $9,000 for payout 1 | $500 | Payouts 1–3: $1,000 / $2,000 / $2,500 / $3,000. Payouts 4–5: $1,000 / $2,500 / $3,000 / $3,500 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay | 50/50 on current profit below $4,000; 80/20 on the part above $4,000 | From funded day one (minimum 1 day), any positive balance | None | $250 | None per payout; you cannot withdraw below the starting balance, and each account is paused at $10,000 gross profit |
| TradeDay Fast Pass | 80/20 | After 5 profitable days of at least $100 / $150 / $200 / $250, with net profit since the last payout and (new accounts) the 45% rule | None | $250 | 50% of profit, up to $750 / $1,500 / $1,875 / $2,250 (accounts opened before July 26, 2026: $2,000 / $2,500 / $3,000 on 50K / 100K / 150K) |
| TradeDay Funded Live | 90/10 | After clearing the live buffer | See the live section | Not published | Not published |
Lucid pays out five times on Pro, Flex and Direct before the account enters its live review pool; LucidDaily has no payout count but a maximum daily profit ($6,000 / $8,000 / $10,000 / $12,000) that triggers the move. TradeDay Fast Pass moves to Funded Live on the fifth payout request; Quick Pay moves on the $10,000 review.
How the Quick Pay split works. TradeDay calculates the split per account on the profit sitting in the account when you request. It publishes three cases on a 50K account:
- $5,000 of profit, request $1,000: the payout leaves $4,000 in the account, so all of it is paid at 80/20 and you receive $800.
- $3,000 of profit, request $1,000: the account is under $4,000, so it is paid at 50/50 and you receive $500.
- $6,000 of profit, request $3,000: the first $2,000 is above the $4,000 line (80% = $1,600) and the last $1,000 is below it (50% = $500), so you receive $2,100.
In practice, the first $4,000 of profit in every Quick Pay account is paid at 50% if you withdraw it, and it is also transferred at 50% if it is still in the account when the account moves to Funded Live (see below). Holding $4,000 in the account is the only way to be paid 80% on the rest.
Two TradeDay source notes. The Quick Pay policy says requests before “5:30 pm ET” are processed by the next business day, while every other TradeDay payout article says 5:30 PM CT; we use CT. The Fast Pass policy and pricing card put the 100K cap at $1,875, while the “What is Fast Pass?” article says $1,850. Lucid’s LucidPro and LucidDirect funded-account overviews also say “No simulated payout caps”, while their payout articles publish the maximums above; we use the payout articles.
Worked first-payout examples at 50K
These assume every day-count, profit-goal and consistency rule is already met. For TradeDay Quick Pay, which has no buffer, we show the request that leaves the same $2,000 cushion above the floor that Lucid’s buffer leaves, and then the all-out request.
| Account (50K) | Profit $3,000: request | You receive | Profit $6,000: request | You receive |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LucidFlex | $1,500 (50% of profit) | $1,350 | $2,000 (cap) | $1,800 |
| LucidPro | $900 (above $52,100) | $810 | $2,000 (payout 1 cap) | $1,800 |
| LucidDaily | $900 (above $52,100) | $810 | $3,900 | $3,510 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay, keeping a $2,000 cushion | $1,000 (all at 50/50) | $500 | $4,000 ($2,000 at 80%, $2,000 at 50%) | $2,600 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay, keeping $4,000 for the 80% rate | Nothing at 80% | – | $2,000 (all at 80/20) | $1,600 |
| TradeDay Quick Pay, everything | $3,000 (leaves the balance on the $50,000 floor) | $1,500 | $6,000 (same) | $3,600 |
| TradeDay Fast Pass (new account) | $1,500 (cap) | $1,200 | $1,500 (cap) | $1,200 |
What this shows: TradeDay Quick Pay lets you take money out earliest and in any size. If you keep a cushion of about $2,000, Lucid’s 90% split pays more at $3,000 of profit ($810 on LucidPro or LucidDaily against $500). Taking everything out of Quick Pay pays $1,500 but leaves the balance on the floor, so the next losing tick ends the account. Quick Pay reaches its 80% rate only when the account carries more than $4,000. Fast Pass pays 80% but caps a 50K at $1,500 a cycle, below every Lucid 50K cap. For more on caps, see how prop firm payout caps work.
The $10,000 Quick Pay review. When any Quick Pay Funded Sim account reaches $10,000 of gross profit, TradeDay pauses it at the 4:30 PM CT end-of-day run and reviews it overnight; most traders are moved to Funded Live. You must stop trading at that level: any profit above $10,000 is removed and is not paid, transferred or carried into an extension. This applies to every account size, so a 150K Quick Pay account is reviewed at the same $10,000 as a 25K.
Payout methods and speed
Lucid: once approved, the payout is deducted from the account within minutes and disbursed “within 2 business days”. US traders can link a bank through Plaid for instant transfers; WorkMarket by ADP serves US and international traders (bank or PayPal, typically next business day); international traders can also take BTC, ETH, LTC, USDT or USDC. Payout requests are final once submitted. If you trade after requesting and drop into the buffer, the request can be denied.
TradeDay: Funded Sim traders request from the dashboard (“Request Withdrawal” appears only when eligible); Funded Live traders email the funded-trader desk. Requests received before 5:30 PM CT are processed within 24 hours on business days, then you withdraw from Riseworks by bank wire or crypto (USDC on Arbitrum for Layer 2). A new request overrides a pending one. On Fast Pass, TradeDay says not to trade again until the payout arrives, and your next five-day cycle starts with the following session. TradeDay runs extra checks on every first payout request, and traders using a VPN can be asked to trade a full day from their registered address before a payout.
We have not tested a payout at either firm; the times above are the firms’ own statements. For full detail, see Lucid Trading payouts and TradeDay payouts.
Moving to a live account and scaling
| Question | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| What triggers a move | Live review pool after payout 5 on Flex, Pro or Direct, the maximum daily profit on LucidDaily, large lifetime payouts or strong sim results; final call by the risk team | Quick Pay: review at $10,000 gross profit per account; most move to Funded Live, some get a Funded Sim extension. Fast Pass: the fifth payout request, or earlier for consistent traders |
| Can you decline | You can take a cashout instead (described as 50% of the live starting balance, 90/10) within 24 hours of the email | Not described |
| Live starting point | $0 balance, EOD drawdown $1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500, no daily loss limit, no consistency rule, daily payouts | Quick Pay: the profit left in the Funded Sim moves across after the split is applied (50/50 below $4,000, 80/20 above). Fast Pass: $0 balance with the tier’s EOD drawdown and a $500 to $1,000 slippage buffer to clear before withdrawing |
| Live split | 90/10 | 90/10, except that on Quick Pay the buffer portion is paid at 50% |
| Live size | 2 / 4 / 6 / 10 minis by funded size, reduced on very volatile contracts | Quick Pay: 2, 3 or 4 minis depending on the balance carried over ($0–3K, $3K–6K, $6K–10K). Fast Pass: 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 minis; increases at the trading team’s discretion |
| Live-only costs | No data charge published in the live articles; swing trading not allowed | CME professional data $156 per exchange per month, broker commissions, slippage rule |
| Bonus | Repeatable Live Bonus ($1,000 / $2,000 / $3,000 / $4,500) after a live profit target and 20 trading days | None published |
| After losing a live account | 2-week cooldown before buying a new evaluation | 3-month cooling-off period, then reapply by email |
| Who cannot go live | If one household member trades live, others may not trade sim | German citizens and Canadians outside Ontario can stay in Funded Sim indefinitely but cannot have Funded Live accounts |
The Quick Pay transfer haircut, in TradeDay’s own numbers. A trader reaches $10,000 of gross profit after taking $3,500 in payouts, so $6,500 is left. At the move to Funded Live, $2,500 transfers at 80% and $4,000 at 50%, so the live account starts with $4,000. The maximum drawdown is then set at $0, and slippage limits and position size follow the balance carried over. TradeDay says a transfer can take up to 10 business days.
Scaling inside the funded stage. TradeDay Fast Pass starts funded accounts below the evaluation size (2 minis on a 50K that allowed 5 in the evaluation) and adds 1 contract for every $2,000 of end-of-day profit. LucidFlex uses a similar plan (2 minis on a 50K under $1,000 of profit, 4 minis from $2,000). LucidPro, LucidDaily and LucidDirect give you full size from day one, as does TradeDay Quick Pay. Lucid’s live terms are covered in more depth in our Lucid Trading live account guide.
Lucid Trading and TradeDay platforms, data feeds, automation and copy trading
Both firms offer CQG and Rithmic routes. NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Quantower, MotiveWave, Bookmap, ATAS, Sierra Chart, Jigsaw, MultiCharts and R|Trader Pro are at both. Tradesea is only at Lucid. EdgeProX, Finamark, VolFix, WealthCharts and Overcharts are only at TradeDay. Yes, Lucid supports TradingView through its CQG connection (you sign into Tradovate first), and so does TradeDay, where you need your own TradingView licence.
TradeDay limits: all your accounts must sit on one broker (you cannot hold a Tradovate evaluation and a Rithmic one at the same time), NinjaTrader Desktop does not work with its Rithmic accounts, and NinjaTrader’s own mobile app does not work with the evaluation (use the Tradovate app). Lucid’s setup steps are in our Lucid Trading platforms and setup guide.
Automation is where the firms split. Lucid says “Automated trading systems and trade copiers are permitted” as long as they follow its rules. TradeDay allows an automated strategy only on NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Jigsaw or Quantower, does not expose platform APIs, does not evaluate systems bought from third parties, and forbids “Algos and Bots purchased from a third party”; if several users make the same trades, all of the accounts are shut down. TradeDay also does not allow a VPS at all, which rules out the usual way of running a bot around the clock.
Copy trading. Both firms allow copiers between your own accounts. At TradeDay you can copy across 2 to 10 evaluation and Funded Sim accounts, or between up to 5 Funded Live accounts, but never between live and sim, and you may not hold open positions in a live and a sim account at the same time. TradeDay also lets you copy trades into it from your own account elsewhere and lists discounts on Tradesyncer, Replikanto and Expert Trading Programmers copiers. Both firms forbid copying other people or trading in concert with them.
Markets: what you can trade
Both firms trade CME Group futures only (CME, CBOT, NYMEX, COMEX): equity indexes, currency futures, energy, metals and agricultural contracts. Neither offers spot forex, CFDs, stocks or crypto futures. The visible difference is interest rates: TradeDay lists 2-, 5- and 10-year notes, the Treasury bond, the Ultra bond and the Ultra note, while Lucid’s approved list has no Treasury futures. TradeDay also lists Micro Euro FX (M6E). TradeDay caps micro positions at 50 lots on every size from 50K up, because of slippage risk in thin micro order books, so a 150K allows 15 minis but not 150 micros. Lucid allows 10 times the mini limit in micros (100 micros at 150K).
Prohibited strategies and trading restrictions
| Rule | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| News trading | Allowed on Pro, Flex and Direct. LucidDaily: flat from 1 minute before to 1 minute after high-impact USD news, or the account is breached | Every account is auto-flattened 2 minutes before FOMC statements and minutes (1:00 PM CT), CPI and Non-Farm Payrolls (7:30 AM CT), plus EIA crude and gas inventories for those contracts and crop reports for grains; trading reopens 2 minutes after. Accidental breaches do not fail you; abuse loses the account, and news profits are withheld if a funded account is lost |
| Bots and algos | Allowed | Own strategy on supported platforms only; bought bots, APIs and VPS banned |
| Hedging | Prohibited within and across accounts, users and firms | Prohibited (long in one account, short in another on the same product); offboarding and forfeited funded profits |
| Microscalping and high frequency | Flagged when more than 50% of profit comes from trades held 5 seconds or less; HFT prohibited (warning, then profits removed and a ban) | Flagged when trades under about 5–10 seconds dominate activity or profit; more than 200 trades a day prohibited; order splitting (several identical orders at one price) prohibited. First instance: reset and warning |
| Trading hours | Flat by 4:45 PM EST (auto-closed, not a breach); reopen 6:00 PM EST | Overnight allowed, but flat 10 minutes before the close; auto-liquidation at 3:50 PM CT (4:50 PM ET), and earlier-closing products are your responsibility |
| Price limits | No specific rule found | Funded traders may not trade within 2% of a CME price limit, or they lose the account |
| VPN and VPS | Circumventing geographic or technical restrictions is prohibited in the terms | VPS not allowed; VPN and IP-masking users must switch them off and may be asked to prove a normal trading day from their registered address at payouts and at the move to live |
| Inactivity | Deleted after 30 calendar days without a $1 net profit or loss | No minimum trading requirement, but accounts dormant for 30 days may be offboarded and Tradovate archives accounts not logged into for a month (counted as failed) |
| Account limits | 10 evaluations, 5 funded, 10 combined per household; 5 live | 10 accounts in total, at most 5 active Funded Sim (extra passes queue) and 5 Funded Live; one username per household; no new purchases while you hold a Funded Live account |
For each firm’s full rulebook, see Lucid Trading rules and TradeDay rules.
Countries, payments and refunds
Restricted countries. The two lists share about 66 countries, including Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, Turkey, Pakistan, Nigeria, South Africa, Morocco, the Philippines, Vietnam, Indonesia, Iceland, Bulgaria and Slovenia. TradeDay also excludes Romania, Croatia, Malta, Monaco, Jordan, Nepal, Cameroon, Guyana, Gibraltar, Palestine, the Cayman Islands and the British Virgin Islands, and the US territories Puerto Rico, Guam and the US Virgin Islands. Lucid also excludes Kenya, Kazakhstan, Lithuania, the Bahamas, Belize, Cambodia, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and the Seychelles, which TradeDay does not list. TradeDay applies its list to both citizenship and residence, and to anyone trading mainly from a listed country while visiting. German citizens and Canadians outside Ontario can trade TradeDay’s Funded Sim but not Funded Live.
Business entities. TradeDay accepts US single-member LLCs for payouts through Riseworks, but not multi-member LLCs, S-corps, C-corps or international businesses.
Paying. Lucid takes Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover, Diners Club and Maestro. TradeDay bills a recurring subscription; its cancellation article refers to your credit card, and you must cancel from the members’ area (logging out does not cancel). TradeDay emails a reminder about four days before each renewal.
Refunds. Lucid has a strict no-refund policy for traded accounts and may consider an untraded one at its discretion. TradeDay refunds nothing after purchase, except a forgotten renewal reported within 72 hours with no trading or third-party connection since, minus 20%, and there are no refunds for platform, data or connection problems.
Reputation, support and published track record
Trustpilot (read October 13, 2026). TradeDay: 4.6 from 1,446 reviews (85% five-star, 6% one-star, 316 in the last 12 months), profile claimed August 2020, replied to 86% of negative reviews. Lucid Trading: 4.4 from 6,880 reviews (86% five-star, 10% one-star, 6,504 in the last 12 months), profile claimed April 2025, replied to 0% of negative reviews. Trustpilot’s own summaries praise fast payouts at both; the recurring complaints are account closures before a payout and unclear support answers at Lucid, and difficulty getting clear answers about account closures at TradeDay. Trustpilot scores reflect who chooses to review.
Published statistics. TradeDay states a 36% evaluation pass rate for January to June 2026 and “$10M+” in payouts since 2020. Lucid’s homepage claims “$700M+ earned by traders”, but we found no pass-rate or payout-rate figure from Lucid. Neither number is audited.
Support. TradeDay lists support@tradeday.com as “Available 24/7” plus live chat on its website, and a separate funded-trader inbox. Lucid offers live chat and tickets 24 hours a day, five days a week, and quotes “Usually 2-4 hours” for a response. Neither publishes a phone number. Current operating notes are on our Lucid Trading status page and TradeDay status page.
Which is better for a beginner?
TradeDay says its evaluation “is not suggested for individuals with minimal trading experience” and points newer traders to its education membership instead; its 36% pass rate is a useful reality check. For a beginner who still wants to try, the cheapest learning route is the one that limits repeat costs: a first-month TradeDay Quick Pay at $59 is cheap, but a month that ends in a fail costs another $59, while a LucidFlex at $90.20 costs nothing more until you buy a reset. TradeDay’s lack of a daily loss limit and its forced flat on major news are simpler to live with; Lucid’s optional daily limit can stop a bad day before it ends the account. Either way, size so that the full drawdown would take several losing days to hit.
Lucid Trading or TradeDay: which firm fits which trader
Lucid Trading tends to suit you if you:
- Want to pay once and not watch a monthly bill while you work on the evaluation.
- Want 90% of every payout from the first one, and your payouts usually sit under $2,000 to $3,500 per request at 50K to 150K.
- Prefer an EOD drawdown once funded (LucidPro, LucidFlex or LucidDirect) with full contract size from day one (Pro, Direct).
- Run a bot or an automated strategy, use a VPS, or trade on Tradesea.
- Trade around CPI, FOMC or payrolls (on Pro, Flex or Direct).
- Want to skip the evaluation (LucidDirect) or pass in a single day (LucidPro).
TradeDay tends to suit you if you:
- Want the cheapest possible first attempt and expect to pass inside a month.
- Want to withdraw from the first funded day with no buffer and no profitable-day count (Quick Pay).
- Can build and keep more than $4,000 in a Quick Pay account so that withdrawals are paid at 80%.
- Want no daily loss limit, overnight sessions, or Treasury futures.
- Value a firm operating since 2020 with a published pass rate and a founder-led team.
- Prefer a free monthly reset over buying resets.
Watch-outs on each side: Lucid’s caps limit big months, LucidFlex pays only 50% of profit per request, LucidDirect’s 20% consistency rule is strict and LucidDaily breaches on red-folder news. TradeDay halves Quick Pay payouts below $4,000 of profit, transfers profit under $4,000 at 50% at the move to live, removes profit above $10,000 at the review, trails the Quick Pay funded drawdown intraday on gross profit, caps Fast Pass payouts at $1,500 on a 50K, bans bought bots and VPS use, flattens you around major data and keeps billing until you pass.
Comparing more firms? See Apex Trader Funding vs Lucid Trading, Lucid Trading vs Topstep, Lucid Trading vs Take Profit Trader, Lucid Trading vs My Funded Futures, Topstep vs TradeDay, TradeDay vs Apex and the full futures comparison hub.
What to verify before choosing Lucid Trading or TradeDay
| Check | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| How many months you will need | TradeDay bills every 30 days until you pass; Lucid does not. |
| The price at checkout | TradeDay’s cards, help centre and launch post show different prices; Lucid’s depend on the DLL choice and code. |
| The funded drawdown type | TradeDay Quick Pay and LucidDaily trail intraday once funded, even after an EOD evaluation. |
| Split versus cap | Lucid: 90% with caps on three plans. TradeDay Quick Pay: no cap but 50% below $4,000 and a $10,000 review. Fast Pass: 80% with a lower cap. |
| Automation and VPS | Allowed at Lucid; bought bots and any VPS are banned at TradeDay. |
| News on your account | TradeDay flattens every account around tier 1 data; Lucid only restricts LucidDaily. |
| Commission on your style | TradeDay’s rates are roughly 1.6 to 1.9 times Lucid’s on index contracts. |
| Country and entity | The restricted lists differ, and TradeDay excludes US territories and limits Germans and most Canadians to Funded Sim. |
What we could not confirm: whether TradeDay’s TDNEW code changes the sale prices on its cards, which of TradeDay’s conflicting reset prices applies at 100K and 150K, how TradeDay’s Quick Pay live “buffer” is sized for each balance band, whether Lucid’s per-side commission includes exchange fees, and how Lucid calculates its live cashout from a $0 starting balance.
Lucid Trading vs TradeDay FAQ
Is Lucid Trading or TradeDay better?
Neither is better for everyone. Lucid suits traders who want a one-time fee, 90/10 from the first payout, EOD funded drawdowns and the freedom to automate. TradeDay suits traders who want the cheapest first month, day-one withdrawals with no buffer on Quick Pay, no daily loss limit and a firm with a published pass rate, and who can live with a monthly fee, a 50/50 split below $4,000 of profit and a forced flat around major data.
Which is cheaper?
For a quick pass, TradeDay. At the sale prices shown on October 13, 2026, a 50K Quick Pay costs $59 (intraday) or $79 (EOD) for the first 30 days, against $75.60 to $115.40 for Lucid’s 50K evaluations with VAULT. Each extra month adds the TradeDay fee again, so by the second month Lucid is usually cheaper. Commissions are lower at Lucid.
Which firm pays out faster?
TradeDay Quick Pay lets you request after one funded day with any positive balance; requests before 5:30 PM CT are processed within 24 business hours, then you withdraw from Riseworks. LucidDaily lets you request daily once you clear its buffer, and Lucid deducts within minutes and disburses within 2 business days. Fast Pass, LucidFlex and LucidDirect need five qualifying days first.
Who owns Lucid Trading?
Lucid Trading is operated by Lucid Trading Group LLC, which lists a Dover, Delaware address. Lucid’s official X account refers to “AJ” as its founder and CEO, and event listings name him as AJ Campanella. TradeDay is owned and run by its co-founders James Thorpe and Steve Miley.
What apps does Lucid Trading use?
Lucid supports NinjaTrader, Tradovate and TradingView through CQG, and Quantower, Tradesea, MotiveWave, Sierra Chart, Jigsaw, Bookmap, ATAS, R|Trader Pro and MultiCharts through Rithmic. It says every listed platform works with every Lucid account type.
How much is Lucid Trading?
Lucid charges a one-time fee: from $79 (25K LucidFlex or intraday LucidDaily) to $836 (150K LucidDirect) at list price, or from $50.30 with the VAULT code and the daily loss limit on. There is no monthly fee and no activation fee; resets are paid.
Does Lucid Trading connect to TradingView?
Yes. TradingView is on Lucid’s CQG route; you sign into Tradovate first and then connect TradingView. TradeDay also connects TradingView through Tradovate, but you need your own TradingView licence.
Can I use a trading bot at either firm?
At Lucid, yes, if the bot follows its rules. At TradeDay, only your own automated strategy on NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Jigsaw or Quantower; bots bought from third parties, direct API connections and VPS hosting are not allowed.
Can I trade news at Lucid or TradeDay?
At Lucid you can on LucidPro, LucidFlex and LucidDirect; LucidDaily breaches if you hold a position from 1 minute before to 1 minute after high-impact USD news. TradeDay flattens every account 2 minutes before FOMC, CPI and payrolls (and EIA or crop reports for those markets) and reopens 2 minutes after.
Which firm has the better drawdown?
For a funded account, LucidPro, LucidFlex, LucidDirect and TradeDay Fast Pass use an EOD drawdown, which ignores open profit until the close. TradeDay Quick Pay and LucidDaily trail intraday. Quick Pay’s floor is also calculated on gross profit, so payouts shrink your cushion. Both firms stop the trail near the starting balance: TradeDay at it, Lucid $100 above it.
Can I hold accounts at Lucid and TradeDay at the same time?
Nothing in either firm’s rules we read forbids it, but both ban hedging, and Lucid names hedging “between different firms”. Do not hold opposite positions at the two firms. TradeDay does allow you to copy your own trades from an outside account into TradeDay.
Is TradeDay legit?
TradeDay has operated since 2020 under TradeDay LLC in Chicago, names its founders and staff, publishes its pass rate and holds a 4.6 Trustpilot score from 1,446 reviews read October 13, 2026. Like Lucid, it runs simulated funded accounts, says it is not registered with the SEC or CFTC, and reserves the right to deny funding or payouts for prohibited practices.
More Lucid Trading research on BestProps
- Lucid Trading review: every plan, support and track record
- Lucid Trading accounts compared: LucidPro vs LucidFlex vs LucidDaily vs LucidDirect
- Lucid Trading payouts and Lucid Trading rules
- Plan guides: LucidPro, LucidFlex, LucidDaily, LucidDirect
- Lucid Trading consistency rule, live accounts and LucidMaxx and platforms and setup
- Lucid Trading deals, status and pulse
- Best alternatives to Lucid Trading and Lucid Trading vs FTMO
- More Lucid Trading guides: LucidBlack legacy rules and payouts
- More Lucid Trading comparisons: Apex Trader Funding vs Lucid Trading, Lucid Trading vs Topstep, Lucid Trading vs My Funded Futures, Lucid Trading vs Take Profit Trader, Lucid Trading vs Tradeify, Alpha Futures vs Lucid Trading, Bulenox vs Lucid Trading, FundedNext Futures vs Lucid Trading and Lucid Trading vs Top One Futures
- TradeDay review, TradeDay payouts, TradeDay rules and TradeDay pulse
- Hubs: all prop firm reviews, payout guides, rule guides, firm status
- Guides: best futures prop firms, prop firms with daily payouts, prop firms for algo trading, prop firms for beginners
Sources
All sources read October 13, 2026.
- Lucid Trading: homepage pricing and plan cards; refund and chargeback policy; contact; terms of use; setup guide; help centre: LucidPro evaluation, LucidPro funded account, LucidPro payouts, LucidPro consistency, LucidPro daily loss limit, LucidFlex evaluation, LucidFlex funded account, LucidFlex payouts, LucidFlex scaling plan, LucidFlex drawdown, LucidDaily evaluation, LucidDaily funded account, LucidDaily payouts, LucidDaily drawdown, LucidDirect funded account, LucidDirect payout objectives, New Live Structure, payout methods, supported platforms, approved products and commissions, other trading activities, allowed trading times, hedging, microscalping, high-frequency trading, inactivity, account limits, payment methods, restricted countries, simulated account fees.
- TradeDay: homepage pricing cards and disclaimers; How It Works; About; TradeDay 2.0 announcement; terms and conditions; help centre: what is TradeDay, who can join, what is Quick Pay, what is Fast Pass, evaluation objectives, consistency, minimum days, maximum drawdown, account sizes, guaranteed funding, after passing, funded rules, Quick Pay payout policy, Fast Pass payout policy, withdrawal frequency, requesting a payout, payout methods, withdrawals and drawdowns, Quick Pay path to live, Fast Pass route to live, funded live rules, Funded Sim vs Funded Live, slippage rule, funded fees, market data, commissions, monthly billing, renewals and resets, cancelling, refund policy, platforms, automated trading, copy trading, multiple accounts, permitted products, position limits, permitted times, tier 1 news, prohibited trade practices, order splitting and microscalping, scalping, VPN and VPS, inactivity, prohibited countries, contact.
- Trustpilot: Lucid Trading and TradeDay.
Lucid Trading vs TradeDay: final word
Lucid Trading and TradeDay both let funded traders take money out early, but they trade off different things. Lucid charges once, pays 90% from the first payout, keeps three of its four plans on an EOD funded drawdown, allows automation and news trading on most plans, and in return caps most payouts and adds profit goals or profitable-day gates. TradeDay is cheaper for a fast first attempt, has no daily loss limit and lets Quick Pay traders withdraw from day one, and in return bills monthly, pays 50% on the first $4,000 of Quick Pay profit, stops each account at $10,000 for a live review, trails the Quick Pay funded drawdown intraday and restricts bots, VPS use and news. Decide which of those trade-offs fits how you trade, then confirm the exact terms at checkout.
This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, investment or trading advice. Futures trading carries substantial risk of loss. Prop-firm terms change often; confirm current rules, prices and payout policies with each firm before you pay.



